Main Street Corridor Design Draws Criticism Over Ten-Foot Paths and Sidewalk Materials

Key Points

  • Main Street redesign concepts draw board concerns regarding 10-foot path requirements and brick durability
  • Select Board requests revisions to 204 Sisson Road fee schedule to increase for-profit rates and lower school costs
  • Harwich nears "Safe Harbor" status with 9.7% affordable housing inventory to prevent hostile 40B developments
  • Approval of $220,092 dredging agreement for Allen Harbor and new conservation restrictions for HCT properties
  • Aquaculture Research Corporation secures four Herring River moorings for shellfish research system

Harwich Center faces a significant transformation as the Select Board reviews conceptual designs for downtown corridor improvements stretching from Sisson Road to Oak Street. During a meeting on Monday, Russ Ple-Camp of Environmental Design and Research (EDR) explained that securing federal Transportation Improvement Program (TIP) funding requires specific infrastructure standards, including ten-foot-wide shared-use paths. These requirements immediately sparked concern regarding the preservation of the village’s aesthetic and practical layout. Ple-Camp noted that that 10-foot wide path may impact parking or trees, prompting board members to advocate for the center's remaining greenery. Member Mark Kelleher emphasized the need for restorative planting, noting that if you look at the historic photos of Harwich Center, they have a lot of nice shade trees, while suggesting that the current landscape suffers from a heat island effect in the summer.

The choice of materials for the project also drew sharp rebukes from the board. Vice Chair Peter Piekarski voiced strong opposition to the inclusion of brick, stating, I think brick sidewalks are a horrendous idea. They don't last. It's probably one of the worst designs for a sidewalk I've walked on. Meanwhile, Member Jeffrey Handler urged the consultants to address immediate visual clutter before adding new features. Whatever we do, we have to maintain whatever trees are left. I really love the orange can for the crosswalk with the crooked sign on it—let's get rid of the orange cans, Handler said. Chair Donald Howell highlighted long-standing safety issues near the Brooks Free Library, pointing out that there is no stop sign coming into Harwich Center eastbound, while also suggesting that the Masonic Lodge might be open to creating indented parking to preserve sidewalk space.

The board also scrutinized a proposed new fee structure for the Cultural Arts Municipal Building at 204 Sisson Road. Director of Cultural Affairs Cara Winnie presented a tiered system intended to replace an outdated $100 hourly rate. Two years ago we went from three hours costing $100 to $100 per hour. We've still included municipal use being zero dollars, Winnie explained, adding that the new plan bolsters for-profit fees. However, the board felt the proposed rates were still inadequate for certain uses. Vice Chair Piekarski argued that the gym is $300 for a half day for a for-profit—it seems like not a drastic difference from a full day. Board members also questioned the logic of charging Harwich-based schools more than non-profits for field use, with Member Handler noting the poor condition of the facility's grounds, which he described as looking like Beirut back there. Chair Howell added that the lack of air conditioning makes long-term summer theater residencies difficult, noting that even 50% off of zero is still zero if you can't use the room because of the heat.

In a move to protect the town’s ability to manage high-density development, Town Administrator James McGrail reported that Harwich is nearing a Safe Harbor designation under state law. With the town’s affordable housing inventory currently at 9.7%, McGrail noted that approving projects like Pine Oaks 4 and Penrose allows the town to maintain control over its destiny. Safe harbor means that if a 40B developer applies for a hostile 40B, we can control our own destiny, McGrail said. Chair Howell warned that opposing these specific projects could backfire for those worried about density. Those people who are adamantly against Pine Oaks 4, if they get their way, we don't have safe harbor, Howell cautioned, explaining that the state grants significant inventory credit for such developments. To further support these efforts, the board discussed amending the Affordable Housing Trust's declaration. Brendan Lowey of the Housing Trust joined the meeting virtually to clarify that the goal is to clarify the language so if the state were to ever change the regulations on AMI, our document would not fight that.

Public comment brought a critical perspective to the board’s recent deliberations regarding citizen petitions. Resident Sally Westgate expressed concern that the board had viewed recent town meeting petitions as a nuisance to be managed, arguing that compiling a list of residents' comments risks undermining the trust and respect essential to good governance. Another resident, Matt Sutphin, provided photographs to the board to refute previous claims regarding a tree removal petition, stating that the board should be more open to new ideas rather than defending the status quo. Despite these tensions, the board reached a warm consensus on a suggestion by Member Anita Doucette to present a plaque to Ella Lombard for her 105th birthday, continuing a town tradition of honoring residents who surpass the century mark.

Infrastructure work continues to ramp up across town as DPW Director Link Hooper announced that the Route 39 Chatham Road intersection begins tomorrow. He also noted that sidewalk work in Harwich Port is nearly finished and a new project on Sisson Street is slated for late June. On the water, Harbor Master John Harker successfully advocated for four new working moorings in the Herring River to support a floating upweller system (Flopsy) for the Aquaculture Research Corporation (ARC). Paul Whittenstein of ARC described the system as looking like a dock that can hold a couple million oysters for research and growth. Local resident Jeff Lang supported the move, noting that aquaculture does it now when it comes to reducing nitrogen in the waterways. Motion Made by J. Handler to close the public hearing. Motion Passed (5-0). Motion Made by M. Kelleher to approve the amendment to the Harbor Management Plan for four working moorings on the Herring River for ARC. Motion Passed (5-0).

Environmental preservation remained a priority as Michael Clark of the Harwich Conservation Trust (HCT) presented new restrictions for Pine Island and Robins Pond Woodlands. Clark noted that these conservation restrictions qualify the Trust for two state grants totaling $650,000 that in turn reduces taxpayer expense. Motion Made by P. Piekarski to approve the conservation restrictions at Pine Island (70 Lothrop Ave) and Robins Pond Woodlands (0 and 61 Northwest Cahoon Road). Motion Passed (5-0). The board also authorized critical maintenance for harbor navigation. Motion Made by M. Kelleher to approve and authorize the chair to sign an intermunicipal agreement with Barnstable County to dredge Allen Harbor, not to exceed $220,092. Motion Passed (5-0). Harbor Master Harker noted that while dredging is essential, repairing the Allen Harbor jetty could eventually reduce the need for such work by 20%.

The board concluded by reviewing several local business applications and administrative changes. Motion Made by P. Piekarski to approve a one-day liquor license and event permit for Harwich Conservation Trust on June 12, 2026. Motion Passed (5-0). Motion Made by P. Piekarski to approve a new Common Victualler application for Cadosia LLC DBA The Bagel Hound at 297 Route 28. Motion Passed (5-0). Motion Made by P. Piekarski to approve a change of manager for Allen Harbor Yacht Club. Motion Passed (5-0). Ahead of the May 21 joint meeting with the Charter Commission, Richard Waystack noted that the commission is seeking a robust conversation on proposed town governance changes, while Art Bodin of the Housing Committee pledged that his group is becoming more proactive in bringing ideas to the Select Board. Finally, Town Administrator McGrail announced that Brendan Bride has been named Acting Building Commissioner to ensure department continuity.